“Ask me first” is not a rule. It is a placeholder, and kids know it — it means you have not decided yet. Most family AI rules sound good until a kid tests them.
Here are eight that hold up, written in language a kid can actually use. Before the list, one thing about how to use it: do not print these and post them on the fridge.
Build your version, don't hand one down
These are a starting point for a conversation, one where your kid gets to weigh in before anything is final. That is not softness, it is strategy: rules a kid helps create are the rules they will apply themselves when you are not in the room.
Go through the list once on your own and circle the five that feel most relevant to your family right now. Then sit down together and build your version. You do not need all eight on day one — you need the ones that fit.
The four foundation rules
Every family needs these, regardless of age and regardless of which tools their kid is using.
- 1AI can help us think, but it can't think for us
Whatever your kid uses it for, they have to be able to explain it in their own words. They hand you an essay on the causes of the Civil War: do not ask whether they wrote it, ask what the third paragraph means. If they can walk you through it, they understand it. If they can't, the AI did the work and they didn't. That is the line.
- 2AI makes mistakes, confidently
It sounds just as certain when it is wrong as when it is right, and only 33% of kids know AI cannot reliably tell fact from fiction. Sources are what catch kids out: ask for a study and it will produce a title, an author and a year that all look real, and the paper does not exist. Check anything important against a real source before it gets turned in.
- 3No personal information
Name, school, address, photos, daily schedule — none of it. And the part most parents do not know: it remembers, and memory is on by default. A kid who mentions their school in March and their coach's name in June has built one profile in an account you do not control. Nobody did anything wrong; it just adds up.
- 4Anything that feels off, scary or confusing comes to us
Not so you can take the phone away — because you want to know. This one only works if you mean it. The first time your kid brings you something weird, how you react decides whether there is a second time.
The four rules about school, people and limits
This is where the rules stop being about the tool and start being about the life around it.
- 1Know the school's policy and follow it
Even when enforcement is inconsistent — and it is. One teacher assigns AI-assisted work on purpose and the teacher across the hall calls the same thing cheating. Your kid is not making that up. The test that outlasts any policy: if you would not be comfortable telling the teacher what you did, you probably should not have done it.
- 2AI isn't a replacement for talking to a person
This is the rule families skip and the one to skip last. A chatbot is available at midnight, never tired, never busy and never disappointed, which is exactly what makes it easier than coming to you. If your kid is going through something hard, the first call is to a person. AI can help sort thoughts; it is not a substitute for actual support.
- 3No AI after the time you pick together on school nights
Not a number handed down — one you agree on and write in. Let your kid argue for a later time than you wanted, because a cutoff they helped choose gets followed and a cutoff you imposed gets tested the first weekend you are not paying attention.
- 4Update the rules together, twice a year
What is appropriate for a ten-year-old is not appropriate for a fourteen-year-old, and half the settings involved will have moved by the time your kid is a grade older. Ten minutes at the kitchen table, twice a year: what is working, what needs to change. Rules that never get updated do not get followed, they get worked around.
Source: Common Sense Media.
What happens when they break one
They will. Not because they are bad kids — because that is what rules are for. A rule nobody ever tests is not a rule, it is a decoration.
The common mistake is leading with the consequence. That ends the conversation in about ninety seconds, and what it actually teaches is: do not get caught.
So the order matters. Find out what happened first, all of it. Then decide what it means. Then — separately, and not the same night — decide what changes. Skip to step three and you get compliance without understanding, and it does not hold.
The wording matters more than the list
“Ask me first” delays the conversation. “You can use it to start, not to finish” is a rule — one of those travels to a friend's house and the other one does not.
The families who do this well are not the most restrictive ones. They are the ones with the clearest rules, and those rules came out of a conversation rather than a list someone downloaded.
Three things to do this week
- •Pick the five rules most relevant to your family right now — not all eight. Write them down.
- •Sit down with your kid and go through them together, to negotiate rather than to announce. Their version will be better than yours in at least one way.
- •Put a date on the calendar six months out to revisit them. Not to check compliance — to check fit.
Common questions
How many AI rules should a family have?
Five is a better starting point than eight. A short list your kid helped write beats a complete list they ignore.
Should I print the rules and put them on the fridge?
Not as the first step. A list posted before the conversation reads as an announcement, and it is the conversation that makes the rules stick. Print it after you have built your version together.
At what age do these rules apply?
All eight apply from about ten upward, but the wording and the cutoff time change with age. Rule eight exists because of exactly that.
What if my kid uses AI at school where the rules differ?
Rule five covers it: follow the school's policy, and use the “would I be comfortable telling the teacher” test where the policy is unclear or inconsistent.
- The 4 questions to ask your teen about AI — have this conversation before you set the rules, not after
- 10 settings to check tonight — the settings that make the rules hold when you are not in the room
Last checked October 2026.
